As anticipated the Times
and Post (I'm sure Safire, Krauthammer, George Will, and others will
join the fray) lambasted Bashar Al-Assad for what is characterized
as Anti-Semitic remarks. I'd like simply point out that the paper's
credibility and defense of Anti-Semitism would have been enhanced
(Arabs are the original semites and only Jews who speak Hebrew are
Semites by the way) had a similar editorial appeared condemning all
the vile words of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef (head of Shas, Israel's third
largest party), Sharon and cabinet ministers who've called for the
murder and expulsion of Palestinians and for the military
reoccupation of Palestinian areas.
The Rabbi called the
Palestinians "evil" and called for their annihilation from the
face of earth.
Speaking in West Jerusalem
during a religious homily, Yosef said that Israel should destroy the
Palestinians mercilessly.
"We must not have mercy on
them, they should get missiles and more missiles, they should be
annihilated, those cursed evil people."
Yosef added that "God will
take deadly revenge against the Arabs, will wipe out their seed, will
annihilate them and defeat them and eliminate them for the face of
earth."
A few months ago, Yosef
described Arabs and gentiles in general as "snakes," saying
"the Lord was regretting having created them."
I don't recall any editorials
condemning his remarks as Anti-Semitic or even inappropriate in an editorial
or by Richard Cohen or anyone else.
Neither of your papers commented
on the Settlers massacres of Palestinians or the Israeli right wing call of
"Let the IDF Win" meaning kill the Palestinians. As far as Assad's
comment that Jews have killed and expelled God's prophets Jesus said the
same thing in Matthew 23:37: "O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, you who kill the
prophets and stone those sent to you, how often I have longed to gather your
children together, as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings, but you were
not willing." As for his comment that Jews are responsible for killing
Christ (not an Islamic belief), Christians for two thousand years have held
that belief which led to an unprecedented Anti-Semitic persecution and
murder of Jews in Europe, not the Middle East.
It is only after the Holocaust
that Christians have not vocalized this belief although many privately still
believe it. Thus we see the politically correct phrase:
"Judeo-Christian" tradition of our country. Perhaps someone should
reread some of the comments on Judaism and religion of our Founding Fathers.
It is also true that the Jews in Arabia conspired many times to kill the
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). Thus his remarks are historically valid but I agree
that they were extremely inappropriate not only for the occasion but goes
against the need for interfaith dialogue, respect, and pursuit of peace
which Israel has defied for 53 years.
Ironically, our media chose not
to highlight the vile anti-Christian reception the Pope received in Israel
or Barak's welcoming words at the airport that Jerusalem is the eternal
undivided capital of Israel. If one would only read the religious beliefs of
ultra-Orthodox Jews one would find the most vile and despicable
characterization of Jesus which stands in sharp contrast to Islam's
veneration of Jesus, peace be upon him (in fact an entire chapter in the
Holy Quran named Mary is devoted to Mary and Jesus, blessed be both of
them).
According to the famed Israeli
Journalist in his column: Galilee (Feb. 25, 2001) he writes:
"Rami Rozen expressed the
Jewish tradition in a long feature in a major Israeli newspaper Haaretz[i]:
“Jews feel towards Jesus today what they felt in 4 c or in the Middle
Ages… It is not fear, it is hatred and despise”. “For centuries, Jews
concealed from Christians their hate to Jesus, and this tradition continues
even now”. “He is revolting and repulsive”, said an important modern
religious Jewish thinker. Rozen writes that this “repulsion passed from
the observant Jews to the general Israeli public”.
On Christmas Eve, according to a
report in the Jerusalem local paper, Kol Ha-Ir[ii], Hassids customarily do
not read holy books, as it could save Jesus from eternal punishment (the
Talmud teaches that Jesus boils in hell[iii]). I still remember old Jews
spitting while passing by a church, and cursing the dead, while passing by a
Christian cemetery.
Last year, the biggest Israeli
tabloid Yedioth Aharonoth reprinted in its library the Jewish anti-Gospel,
Toledoth Eshu, compiled in the Middle Ages. It is the third recent reprint,
including one in a newspaper. If the Gospel is the book of love, Toledoth is
the book of hate for Christ. The hero of the book is Judas. He captures
Jesus by polluting his purity. According to Toledoth, the conception of
Christ was in sin, the miracles of Jesus were witchcraft, his resurrection
but a trick.
Joseph Dan, a Professor of
Jewish mysticism in Hebrew University in Jerusalem, writing on the death of
Jesus stated: “The modern Jewish apologists, hesitantly adopted by the
church, preferred to put the blame on Romans. But the medieval Jew did not
wish to pass the buck. He tried to prove that Jesus had to be killed, and he
was proud of killing Him. The Jews hated and despised Christ and
Christians”. Actually, adds Prof. Dan, there is little place to doubt that
the Jewish enemies of Jesus caused his execution.
Even today, Jews in Israel refer
to Jesus by the demeaning word Yeshu (instead of Yeshua), meaning ‘Perish
his name’."
Oddly, the NYTimes editorial
shed confusion as to what happened in Qunietra, the Golan Heights. I didn't
think the Times, the pillar of record, would so distort historical truth. In
1974, the US forced Israel to withdraw from the city. While withdrawing
Israel demolished the city. That's a point of record in the U.N. and State
Dept. Israel even then did not deny it so why the deliberate confusion? Even
more shocking is that the Times yesterday had a story on the Pope's visit
titled: May 7, 2001 Pope Prays for Peace at City Destroyed by Israel By
ALESSANDRA STANLEY
Of course I could waste my time
and write letters in response but it's obvious that my letters and those of
other Arab/Muslim American letters are not welcome in your papers especially
if they are critical of Israel or of our pandering Congress. I even wrote a
letter a couple of days ago on the US being kicked out of the Human Rights
Commission (see below) that was not used but three letters were published on
the subject. It's fascinating how an Israeli or Jewish issue generates so
many published letters (5) as is the case today on Elie Wiesel's
hypocritical column on forgiveness.
I have not seen editorials on
the murder of the four month old Palestinian baby, on Israel's nightly
bombardment of refugee camps, or on the Mitchell report that Sharon rejects.
It does seem obvious that
"Vile Words Against Israel Are Far More Painful than Vile Bombs Against
Palestinian children". As I've told you both, for months in 1982 Sharon
was killing civilians much faster than I could save them. By the way, Bush
is supporting Israel's request for millions of dollars to compensate the
depleted weapons Israel has lost in Palestinian bodies. I haven't seen that
reported. I understand your position as two editorial employees of two
Jewish owned papers but I still subscribe to the view that there is no
Zionist media conspiracy to only show Israel's positive civilized democratic
behavior and exclude or only paint Palestinians as terrorists.
Israel will win the military and
public relations battle thanks to you for sometime. But as I travel and
speak to people, many are realizing the truth despite the best efforts of
our media. It's only a matter of time before someone is brave enough to
speak the truth and given America's changing demographics, Israel is bound
to lose our tax-dollars and weapons and then what. The world is finding some
courage to stand up to America's power and weight. It's odd how our media
elite and politicians are thinking of their short term monetary gain and
stability rather than humanity's future and peace.
I write you because your papers
have made a conscience decision to disallow my viewpoint that counters
Israel's lies. Thank God for the internet.
Mr. Mohamed Khodr is an American
Muslim physician and a native from the Middle East. He has worked in
Academic Medicine and Public health with national and international
health experience. He is a freelance writer who often writes columns
on the Palestinian cause, Islam and on America's Foreign Policy in the
Middle East. He lives in the Washington DC area.
by the same author: