by Tom Mitsoff
Money talks, and ballplayers are listening.
If you don’t believe it, ask fans in two-thirds of the Major League
Baseball cities around the U.S. and Canada. Even though spring training
camps haven’t even opened for the 2002 season, they know that their
teams are already effectively dead in the water.
Why? Because, being intelligent capitalists, ballplayers go where the
money is. After six years in the majors, players have the right to
declare their free agency and sign with whichever team they choose. As
predicted 25 years ago when players won their right to move freely from
team to team, the top players have flocked to the teams with the most
money, which have in turn become the top teams in the sport.
Recent history proves it. In the past 10 years, every team that has won
the World Series has been among the top 10 in payroll. In 2001, six of
the eight playoff teams were among the top 10 in payroll.
Effectively, 20 out of the 30 teams will show up each day, play their
games, sell their tickets and concessions, operate their businesses and
have absolutely no hope of winning the World Series.
For most of the sport’s history, teams that stunk up the joint had at
least a sporting chance to improve by bringing in new management or by
making shrewd trades. In the new millennium, two-thirds of major league
teams face the reality that even very skilled executives cannot trade
for or sign certain players who could help their teams, due to budget
limitations.
Other sports have seen their average player salaries balloon into the
millions as well, but the NFL and NBA are not facing a similar
competitive crisis. Like baseball, those sports have their wealthy and
not-so-wealthy franchises. Unlike baseball, those sports have salary
caps -- limits on how much money teams can spend on player salaries.
In the NFL, the worst team and the best team have the same ceiling on
what they can spend on player salaries. What that does is keep all of
the top players from congregating on three or four teams. And with just
a few shrewd acquisitions and good coaching, a team in the NFL can come
off the scrap heap like the St. Louis Rams did in 1999. In ‘98, they won
four games and lost 12, one of the league’s worst records. The next
year, they won 13, lost only three and went on to win the Super Bowl.
One reason the Rams were able to make such a complete reversal of
fortunes is that their primary rivals couldn’t respond by going out and
buying players to try to match their improvements. Foes were forced to
face the Rams with the players they had since they couldn’t add
salaries.
In baseball, it has become an annual rite of passage for the New York
Yankees to spend the first couple of months of the season evaluating at
which positions they are weaker than expected or weaker than their top
rivals. Then they go out and trade for better players from bottom-tier
teams who can’t afford them or who know they will be losing them after
the season anyway.
Give the Yankees credit for being excellent judges of baseball talent.
Just because someone signs a big contract doesn’t guarantee he will be a
star. But more often than not, the Yankees are able to find the ones who
are standout major league players.
But if there was a mandatory cap on salaries, many of the current
Yankees (as well as players on the other wealthy clubs) would have to be
shipped off to other teams. It wouldn’t be good for the Yankees, but it
certainly would be good for the long-term competitive balance of the
sport as a whole.
The Montreal Expos, baseball’s worst team, are on life support. The only
way they’ll play this season is if the rest of the sport’s owners decide
to subsidize their existence. Their fans have known for many years that
they don’t have a chance to sign the better players, and they have
finally lost interest. The same will continue to happen in other cities
until the time baseball ownership and the players’ union both wake up
and realize that a salary cap is needed.
Baseball is still our greatest game, but even the passionate fans won’t
stay forever when their teams are merely perennial fodder for the
sport’s elite.
Mr.
Tom Mitsoff is a daily newspaper editor and syndicated
editorial columnist. His web address is
http://www.tommitsoff.com.
Source: