Sign in
  • Home
  • Perspectives
  • Articles
  • Columns
  • Platform
  • Poetry
    • Literature
  • Shop
    • Cart
    • My account
  • Give
    • Donation Confirmation
  • Contribute
Sign in
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
Search
53.6 F
Los Angeles
Saturday, February 16, 2019
  • Sign in / Join
  • Contact MMN
  • en English
    af Afrikaanssq Albanianam Amharicar Arabichy Armenianaz Azerbaijanieu Basquebe Belarusianbn Bengalibs Bosnianbg Bulgarianca Catalanceb Cebuanony Chichewazh-CN Chinese (Simplified)zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)co Corsicanhr Croatiancs Czechda Danishnl Dutchen Englisheo Esperantoet Estoniantl Filipinofi Finnishfr Frenchfy Frisiangl Galicianka Georgiande Germanel Greekgu Gujaratiht Haitian Creoleha Hausahaw Hawaiianiw Hebrewhi Hindihmn Hmonghu Hungarianis Icelandicig Igboid Indonesianga Irishit Italianja Japanesejw Javanesekn Kannadakk Kazakhkm Khmerko Koreanku Kurdish (Kurmanji)ky Kyrgyzlo Laola Latinlv Latvianlt Lithuanianlb Luxembourgishmk Macedonianmg Malagasyms Malayml Malayalammt Maltesemi Maorimr Marathimn Mongolianmy Myanmar (Burmese)ne Nepalino Norwegianps Pashtofa Persianpl Polishpt Portuguesepa Punjabiro Romanianru Russiansm Samoangd Scottish Gaelicsr Serbianst Sesothosn Shonasd Sindhisi Sinhalask Slovaksl Slovenianso Somalies Spanishsu Sudanesesw Swahilisv Swedishtg Tajikta Tamilte Teluguth Thaitr Turkishuk Ukrainianur Urduuz Uzbekvi Vietnamesecy Welshxh Xhosayi Yiddishyo Yorubazu Zulu
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Media Monitors Network (MMN) Media Monitors Network (MMN)
Media Monitors Network (MMN) Media Monitors Network (MMN)
  • Home
  • Perspectives
    • Myanmar/Burma Little hope for Rohingya IDPs
      Perspectives

      The Myth of ‘Bengali Migration’ to Arakan

      Faisal Mosque - Pakistan
      Perspectives

      Pakistan: How to Change Political Culture of Corruption and Rebuild the…

      Disappearing Palestine
      Perspectives

      In Hebron, Israel removes the last restraint on its settlers’ reign…

      No to Sexism Racism Homophobia Xenophobia
      Perspectives

      Racism in our time: Can it be defeated?

      Jerusalem Israel Palestine Dome of The Rock Golden Dome
      Perspectives

      Clover Sellout to Apartheid Israel Faces Resistance

  • Articles
    • Man studying religious book
      Articles

      Ishmael and Isaac: An Essay on the Divergent Moral Economies of…

      Mahmoud Abbas
      Articles

      May Your Home Be Destroyed

      Netanyahu Lighting Hanukah Candles with His Wife and Sons
      Articles

      Bibi’s Son or: Three Men in a Car

      The Map of Greater Israel
      Articles

      The Man Who Jumped

      West Bank - Palestine
      Articles

      Cry, Beloved Country

  • Columns
    • United States Capitol Building, Washington, D.C.
      Columns

      Game Over!

      Bernie Sanders
      Columns

      Bernie 2020 Campaign Has Corporate Democrats Running Scared

      Pope Francis
      Columns

      Why the Events Surrounding Pope Francis’ UAE Visit Were So Important

      Democrats
      Columns

      As the 2020 Presidential Contest Begins, Democrats Need to Refocus

      Disappearing Palestine
      Columns

      Michelle Alexander Has Opened a Door, We Must Work to Keep…

  • Platform
    • Hanukkah Lights
      Platform

      Hanukkah is not hypocrisy

      The Washington Post
      Platform

      “Preemptive war could risk millions of casualties. But….”

      Platform

      When they shout: "We strongly condemn…"

      68
      Platform

      Why Iran won’t attack Israel

      Platform

      Is One Iraqi’s Self-Hatred Newsworthy?

  • Poetry
    • Literature
  • Shop
    • Cart
    • My account
  • Give
    • Donation Confirmation
  • Contribute
Home Articles The 1948 Arab Invasion of Israel Deconstructed
  • Articles

The 1948 Arab Invasion of Israel Deconstructed

By
Ronald Bleier
-
September 8, 2003
Share
Facebook
Twitter
Google+
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Linkedin
ReddIt
Email
Print
Tumblr
Telegram
StumbleUpon
VK
Digg
LINE
Viber

    Israeli novelist David Grossman’s article, "Guests Can Be Shown the Door," in the New York Times Magazine " looked at the discrimination Palestinians face as a minority in Israel (December 13, 1992, p. 40). In it Grossman also repeated one of the half-truths about the birth of Israel that has sustained Zionists in Israel and in the West since 1948. An examination of some of the circumstances surrounding the Arab invasion of Israel in May 1948 reveals how accounts such as Grossman’s continue to distort history.

    Eight paragraphs into his article, Grossman wrote that although Israel’s Palestinians "enjoy full equality…in practice they are discriminated against in almost all areas of life." The "tragedy" of Israeli discrimination against its Arab citizens "came into being on May 14, 1948, when Israel declared its independence. Immediately thereafter, five Arab armies invaded, determined to destroy it. The war was long and bloody, and when it ended only 156,000 Arabs were left within Israel: they now number some 900,000…18 percent of Israel’s population."

    The traditional picture Grossman portrayed of a hapless Israel, struggling for its existence against implacable Arab armies, began to crumble in the early 1980s with the publication of the diaries of Moshe Sharett (1979) and David Ben Gurion?s War Diaries (1982) and with the release of thousands of declassified documents from the Israeli State Archives. The new information led to the appearance of important books and articles revising previous notions of the birth of Israel by such Jewish and non-Jewish writers as Simha Flapan, Livia Rokach, Benny Morris, Avi Shlaim, Tom Segev, Michael Palumbo and others.

    The New Historians

    Simha Flapan, perhaps the most accessible of the "revisionist," historians, played an active role during the war of 1948 as a member of Mapam, the United Workers Party. In his landmark book, The Birth of Israel: Myths and Realities (New York: Pantheon, 1987) Flapan wrote that "like most Israelis, I had always been under the influence of certain myths that had become accepted as historical truth" (p. 8).

    Flapan divides his book into seven sections, each addressing a myth associated with the birth of Israel. Examining "Myth Five," Flapan argues that it was not the Arab invasion which brought on war, but rather the decision by the Jewish leadership to declare statehood on May 14. Flapan contends that documents show that the "Arabs had agreed to a last minute American proposal for a three-month truce on the condition that Israel temporarily postpone its Declaration of Independence. Israel’s provisional government rejected the American proposal by a slim majority of 6 to 4." (p. 9)

    Ethnic Cleansing, 1947

    The reason the Americans and the international community were alarmed as May 14 approached was that a calamitous communal war had broken out immediately after passage of the U.N. Partition Resolution of November 29, 1947. In the war between the stronger Jewish forces and the less prepared Arab community, parallels can be drawn to the ethnic cleansing that is going on in Bosnia.

    Like the Serbs today, the Jewish forces generally did everything they could to force the Palestinians to flee their cities, towns and villages. The Arab flight which numbered 60,000 by the end of March 1948, increased dramatically after April 9, 1948, the date of the infamous Dir Yassin massacre, when Menachem Begin’s Irgun (with the tacit complicity of Ben-Gurion’s Haganah) slaughtered more than 100 civilians from a "friendly" Arab village near Jerusalem.

    News of the massacre, including cases of rape, spread quickly throughout the Arab community and led to the terrified mass flight of civilians in search of safety. Before the middle of May ’48 almost 300,000 Palestinians had fled.

    Avoiding Repatriation

    One reason that Ben-Gurion opted for Statehood on May 14 despite international opposition was because he understood that if he held back and a truce was effected, a new Israeli State might well be forced to repatriate the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians already made refugees. Moreover, by mid-May, there remained more than 500,000 Palestinians in areas that the Jewish forces controlled or desired for their state. Ben-Gurion had no intention of allowing such a large Arab minority to remain in Israel and therefore he chose war. In the end, more than 750,000 Palestinians were exiled forever from their homes.

    Flapan also argues that an unprepared Arab nation entered the war reluctantly. The Arab forces were divided politically and, contrary to myth, they were no match for the Jewish forces in numbers either.

    Flapan cites figures which indicate that the combined Arab armies totaled no more than 25,000 troops; including 10,000 Egyptian troops, 4,500 Transjordanian troops and perhaps 3,000 troops from Palestine itself, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon respectively. In contrast, all estimates of front-line Jewish troops, united under a single command, put the number at least at 25,000. In addition, some estimates of Jewish forces are as high as 60,000 or 90,000 more if settlement troops, irregular forces and others are counted. (Flapan, p. 196) With these figures in mind, it is easier to see how Ben-Gurion could gamble on a unilateral declaration of the state of Israel on May 14, and war.

    Qualified Sympathy

    That Grossman ignored these findings goes hand in hand with his remarks a few paragraphs later that reveal the gap that exists between himself and the Palestinians — despite the sympathy he also expressed. Grossman mentions instances of anti-Arab discrimination such as the fact that there has never been in Israel an Arab Supreme Court Justice, nor has there been an "Arab member of the executive committee of the Israel Broadcast Authority." Moreover, as he noted "half of those living under the poverty line in Israel are Arabs?These are grave facts." Yet, once again he went on to qualify these facts with his own notion of "the geopolitical circumstances in which this serious discrimination was born and preserved." Israel’s four million Jews, he reiterated, "feel–with justice — that they are a miniscule and ever-threatened minority in the midst of the enormous Muslim world surrounding them."

    Here he ignores the reality of an Israel, with U.S. backing, as the dominant power of the region. Today we find a post-Gulf War Middle East where Egypt is marginalized and Iraq is shattered and isolated. Syria — the only remaining, semi-independent adversary–has reason to fear each time top Israeli military leaders speak openly of the need to attack it. Grossman failed to take into account the fact that Israel’s control of Arab territory and water resources in Palestine, Syria and Lebanon is the critical reason for an unstable and hostile Middle East.

    While Grossman spoke of the six wars that Israel has endured, he did not mention that Israel either initiated or was indirectly responsible for all of them — including the October 1973 War which was a consequence of Golda Meir’s hardline policy of refusing to make any concession to the Arabs.

    Who Suffers?

    He spoke of the Arab countries’ economic boycott by the Arab countries and of Israel as the target of terrorist attacks, but said nothing about the Arabs’ legitimate fears in the region. He then made the following statement: "On the average, since Israel was born, there has been almost no day in which an Israeli citizen has not suffered injury from an Arab." Since Grossman cited no figures to back up this statement, one can only guess at the nature of the injuries that he includes. Does he refer to violent attacks, or does he include verbal insults and accusing glances? His emphasis on Israeli suffering without placing it in the context of the oppression and suffering Palestinians have endured every day since 1948 betrays the denial, even by many Israeli intellectuals, of the darker side of the birth of Israel.

    By referring to the "injuries" perpetrated daily by Arabs, Grossman allowed for further "moral" justification for what the Israelis euphemistically call "transfer," — the mass expulsion of the Palestinian people from what remains of their homeland. The Rabin government’s decision in mid-December to expel 415 Palestinians from the Occupied Territories illustrates how quickly and easily such intolerance can be translated into action.

    At the beginning of his article, Grossman described an incident in Israel at a summer camp for Jewish and Arab youngsters. The example he chose highlighted the fears of a Jewish boy of about 14, "a somewhat clumsy and pale type" who ran away into the forest rather than spend the night in a tent with Arab boys. Once we understand that what Grossman relates can be used as a rationale for expelling the "Other," just as it was in 1948, the choice of anecdote and the article’s title, "’Guests Can Be Shown the Door,’" seem to make more sense. Grossman’s clumsy boy can be interpreted as a symbol of Jewish Israelis, trapped in fear and hysteria by their leadership and by their nation’s history of oppressing the Palestinians in their midst.

    Did you like this article?

       

    Awesome, share it:

    Share Tweet Google Plus LinkedIn

    Thanks!

    Thanks for getting in touch with us.

    Click here (New window) to subscribe to our Newsletter

    • TAGS
    • 1948
    • about
    • account
    • accounts
    • action
    • addressing
    • after
    • again
    • against
    • allowed
    • almost
    • already
    • always
    • American
    • americans
    • april
    • Arab
    • Arabs
    • archives
    • areas
    • armies
    • article
    • attack
    • attacks
    • authority
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Google+
    Pinterest
    WhatsApp
    Linkedin
    ReddIt
    Email
    Print
    Tumblr
    Telegram
    StumbleUpon
    VK
    Digg
    LINE
    Viber
      Previous articleThe Thunder Jet
      Next articleThe first two years of Insanity
      Ronald Bleier

      Mr. Ronald Bleier is Editor of DESIP and he contributed this article to Media Monitors Network (MMN).

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      Man studying religious book
      Articles

      Ishmael and Isaac: An Essay on the Divergent Moral Economies of the Quran and the Torah

      Mahmoud Abbas
      Articles

      May Your Home Be Destroyed

      Netanyahu Lighting Hanukah Candles with His Wife and Sons
      Articles

      Bibi’s Son or: Three Men in a Car

      MMN @ Google Play Store MMN @ Amazon Appstore

      MMN @ TwitterMMN @ FacebookMMN Feed

      Newsletter

      LATEST

      United States Capitol Building, Washington, D.C.

      Game Over!

      James Zogby - February 16, 2019
      Myanmar/Burma Little hope for Rohingya IDPs

      The Myth of ‘Bengali Migration’ to Arakan

      February 16, 2019
      Faisal Mosque - Pakistan

      Pakistan: How to Change Political Culture of Corruption and Rebuild the Future?

      February 15, 2019

      MOST POPULAR

      Talking Zionism

      July 29, 2012

      Deceive, Divide, and Devour :: The uses and meanings of "disengagement"...

      August 16, 2005

      Journalists under Fire

      November 16, 2000

      Nader: What Impact?

      March 9, 2004
      Load more

      EDITOR PICKS

      United States Capitol Building, Washington, D.C.

      Game Over!

      February 16, 2019
      Myanmar/Burma Little hope for Rohingya IDPs

      The Myth of ‘Bengali Migration’ to Arakan

      February 16, 2019
      Faisal Mosque - Pakistan

      Pakistan: How to Change Political Culture of Corruption and Rebuild the...

      February 15, 2019

      POPULAR POSTS

      167

      The Origin of Freemasonry: The Crusaders & Templars

      April 23, 2003

      Sharon to Peres: We Control America

      November 20, 2001
      29

      Afghanistan, the Taliban and the United States

      May 2, 2001

      POPULAR CATEGORY

      • Perspectives13431
      • Columns1130
      • Articles859
      • Platform37
      • Poetry12
      • Literature6
      Media Monitors Network (MMN)
      ABOUT US
      Media Monitors Network (MMN) is a non-profit, non-partial and non-political platform for those serious Media Contributors and Observers who crave to know and like to help to prevail the whole truth about current affairs, any disputed issue or any controversial issue by their voluntarily contributions with logic, reason and rationality.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      • About MMN
      • Disclaimer
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Contact
      © Copyright © 2000 - MMN International Inc. All rights reserved.
      Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
      ResponsiveVoice-NonCommercial licensed under 95x15
      MORE STORIES

      The Presbyterians and Israel

      August 5, 2004

      Roadmap: A Fantasy or Short-Lived Love?

      February 20, 2004
      Edit with Live CSS
      Save
      Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete.